Skip to content Skip to navigation

The Problem with Assuming Athens

Monday, November 16, 2026 - 09:00

None of the articles in this collection are adding much new information to my understanding of the historical context, but they sure are satisfying my longing for critiques of Foucault.

Major category: 
Full citation: 

DuBois, Page. 1998. “The Subject in Antiquity after Foucault” in David. H. J. Larmour, Paul A. Miller, and Charles Platter (eds), Rethinking Sexuality: Foucault and Classical Antiquity. Princeton: Princeton University Press. ISBN 9780691016795

The Subject in Antiquity after Foucault

This article concerns itself with the relationship of the individual to their society – whether “people are people” or whether individuals have meaning specifically in relation to the society they inhabit. To explore this, the author uses the work of Sappho as a lens. The author is concerned by the absence of gender as a consideration in Foucault’s classical discussions, in part because it assumes the centrality of men and the subjugation of women, as well as envisioning Greek society as a reflection of the rarified environment of the (masculine) symposium resulting in a flattening of vision. This vision valorizes the austere, self controlled philosopher, who always remains above the experience of passions and appetite. The subject, within Foucault’s explorations, is always conceived of as male. Not even a generic “man as representing humanity” but a male person who is assumed to have a wife and to be in a position of power over all those around him who are not also adult men. Women exist only for a male subject to experience, react to, and control oneself with respect to.

This position is difficult to maintain if one looks beyond the writings of Greek philosophers and considers depictions of everyday experience in drama and poetry. While the poetry of Sappho has been the subject of speculation and mythologization (in various directions) it exists – unless one is reading Foucault, in which case it does not exist.

In general, scholars of ancient sexuality show a surprising disinterest in Sappho as a data source, perhaps because she is not Athenian, or because her early date makes comparative material scarce, but this very narrowing of the scope of interest means that Athenian culture of a specific timeframe is made to stand in for Greek culture in general, and thus – given the place of Greece in the collective western imagination – to stand in for the source of western civilization itself.

The author argues that Sappho is excluded from these considerations specifically because she is a woman writing about sex between women and about female desire. She is not a “threat” to civilization as envisioned by Foucault, but to include her would require a massive reformulation of Foucault’s picture of austerity, male primacy, and female subjugation. The author points out that, in contrast to the embrace of Foucault by historians with a more modern focus, classicists tend to dismiss his work for reasons that will be detailed in Amy Richlin’s article (to follow). But du Bois also feels that Richlin assumes a universal category of “women” that can be studied apart from their historic context.

Instead she wishes to focus on what Foucault’s “classical Greek philosophy of sex” displaced – on the precursors it developed in reaction to, to the extent that we can know it. Sappho is part of that “prehistory” and erasing her creates a flawed vision of the past.

That said, the Foucaultian approach of “defamiliarization” of the past can be productively applied to interpreting Sappho, as it permits us to construct an understanding of her world from her work itself, rather than assuming a projection from the present.

Using this approach, du Bois discusses several passages from Sappho’s poems and points out contexts where assumptions or interpretations can produce entirely different understandings of her context, such as the tendency to interpret references to persons in a way that construct a “normative” family structure, comfortable for modern sensibilities. (The specific interpretations the author suggests are not definitive – nothing can be – but rather point out opportunities.)

One of du Bois’s points is that Foucault’s approach to studying the history of sexuality can be applied even to areas (like “women”) that he ignored. He can encourage the historian to avoid universalizing the category “woman” and making essentialist assumptions about women’s place and nature.

The author asks questions like a “was Sappho’s identity as an aristocrat more relevant than her identity as a woman?”

Toward the end of the article, it veers into modern sexual politics and Foucault’s place in them.

Time period: 
Place: 
Event / person: 
historical