Skip to content Skip to navigation

LHMP

Blog entry

While some other articles in this collection focus on how Foucault's fixation with Athenian philosophical circles ignores the wider classical world, this article notes how his picture also ignores the complexity of Athenian society outside those philosophical debates.

None of the articles in this collection are adding much new information to my understanding of the historical context, but they sure are satisfying my longing for critiques of Foucault.

Although this collection of papers doesn't add much in the way of new information to my understanding of the history of sexuality, it was peculiarly satisfying to read with respect to The History of Sexuality. My regular readers will know that I have...um...issues with that book. It's gratifying to read other people's issues with it--in great and meticulous detail.

Any time an intriguing historical figure has a dearth of factual information available, there is an inevitable impulse to envision the unknown details of their life When historical novelists do this, we can get vividly imagined stories. When historians do it...well, we often get factoids that are then passed along and circulated uncritically. Somewhere in between the novelists and the historians are all the modern lesbians projecting their hopes, dreams, and desires onto Sappho.

It's pretty rare for me to cover any publications that deal exclusively with male same-sex topics, but this article laying out the case for the "marriage-like" symbolism in the tomb of two ancient Egyptian men is worth studying for the process of analysis. Brief references to this couple show upregularly in "sound-bite" queer history contexts, but the full context is both more interesting and less straightforward.

When we know essentially nothing about the personal lives of people being referenced in intriguing ways, the temptation for historians is always to fill in the details with speculation or assumption. But that's when the world-view of the person doing the speculating and assuming can have an outsized impact on how the facts are interpreted for posterity.

Lesbian Historic Motif Podcast - Episode 356 - On the Shelf for November 2026 - Transcript

(Originally aired 2026/11/07)

Welcome to On the Shelf for November 2026.

Many people have tried to relate Lucian's 5th Dialogue of the Courtesans either to actual Roman attitudes towards women's same-sex relationships, or to the reality of those relationships. The problem is that, not only is any underlying truth filtered through an elite male author, there isn't always agreement on what Lucian's purpose was in writing the dialogues. Bissa tries to use internal evidence in the text to tackle some of these questions.

Lesbian Historic Motif Podcast - Episode 355 – The Sultan’s Vetala by Priya Sridhar - transcript

(Originally aired 2026/10/31)

I love it when we not only get a fiction episode at the end of October, but we have a story to schedule that partakes of the supernatural or a touch of horror. When I suggested to Priya that we might air this story on Halloween, she was delighted by the idea.

Often when a book or article brings in literary criticism to discuss a historic topic, I feel like it's more of an intellectual game. But in this case, it really does feel like the literary and the real-life aspects are so solidly braided together that the approach makes sense.

Pages

Subscribe to LHMP
historical